We have 10 species of thistle in Nebraska, 5 native (tall, Platte, Flodman's, yellowspine, and wavyleaf) and 5 non-native (plumeless, musk, Canada, bull, and Scotch). Nebraska Extension Acreage Team Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County Lincoln, NE 68528, Phone: (402) 441-7180 Email: sbrowning2@unl.edu. Figure 2C. … Native thistle provide important habitat and food sources for native fauna. Native thistles are usually found as single plants or in small clumps rather than the expansive stands often formed by non-native thistles. The large flower heads and flower density of many native thistles encourages greater visitation by pollinators. The Bull thistle was used by early humans as a warm medicinal tea. Integrated Taxonomic Information System. Answer: Both thistles and nettles have been called the devil’s plant or devil’s vegetable because of their thorns, and both are considered prickly weeds, although they’re often used medicinally. Bull thistle gene… Bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare) has lobed leaves with sword-shaped sections, and scary spines at the tips. The spread of non-native thistles presents environmental and agricultural problems that people expend great effort to address. Figure 2A. Biennial thistles spread only by seed (achenes) that are produced in great number by all the noxious species, ran… Weedy characteristics: Scotch thistle is highly competitive and aggressive, and forms dense colonies that can choke out native vegetation. To the best of my knowledge, there are no fully reliable physical characteristics to distinguish all native thistles from non-native thistles, but in general, native thistles tend to be less spiny with the spines more localized on leaf margins. Scotch thistle can be confused with bull thistle (Cirsium vulgaris), which is also sometimes called "Scotch thistle" and is much more common in western Washington. thistles also feed on bull thistle. For more information, see Noxious Weed Lists and Laws or visit the website of the Washington State Noxious Weed Contro… This article focuses on why we should keep native thistles around and start thinking of them as "wildflowers" rather than "weeds". Lobes on leaves are tipped with stout spines. The Value of Native Thistles Custom programming and server maintenance by. Many species of thistles have edible roots, inner stems, young leaves, young inner parts of flower buds and seeds. 2003. ... Scotch thistle is a slow-growing biennial. Some parts of this site work best with JavaScript enabled. Working in partnership with the Nebraska Game and Parks Commission. She also has some experience with habitat improvement projects. Identify Scotch thistle by its rich purple blooms and the thick, spiky hairs on its leaves. ---Description---It is a biennial, flowering in late summer and autumn. Legend has it that in the tenth century, the invading Danes gave themselves away by their screams when they tried to steal away barefoot through a dry moat full of thistles. Common name(s): Bull thistle, spear thistle Scientific name: Cirsium vulgare Family: Sunflower or Aster family (Asteraceae) Reasons for concern: This aggressive and persistent species can quickly take over both disturbed and unattended areas, and outcompete native species, reducing plant diversity and wildlife habitat. Overview Information Scotch thistle is a plant. For example, non-native bull thistle and native tall thistle share over 80% of their herbivore community. Description . Scotch thistle (Ono-pordum acanthium), See 4E and 5E on pages 4 and 5. This thistle plant I’m testing is a bull thistle, and the spines are huge and rigid. The Silybum marianum plant goes by many different names, including Scotch thistle, holy thistle, Mary thistle, variegated thistle, and milk thistle. Yellowspine . Our native thistles tend to get a bad reputation right along with the non-natives even though native thistles do not typically exhibit the same invasive, weedy tendencies. Prevalence and impact of the crown fly, Botanophila spinosa, on its host thistle, Onopordum acanthium, in southern France. Erin grew up in southeastern Nebraska roaming around the farm land of her parents’ home and the adjacent state Wildlife Management Area and State Recreation Area. Many native thistles also have thick, white hairs on the underside of leaves, giving the leaves a two-toned appearance; light on bottom, darker on top. As nouns the difference between thistle and burdock is that thistle is any of several perennial composite plants, especially of genera cirsium'', ''carduus'', ''cynara or , having prickly leaves and showy flower heads with prickly bracts while burdock is any of the species of biennial thistles in the genus arctium . BONUS: You’ll also receive our Almanac Companion newsletter! The next time you jump on your ATV to address noxious and invasive vegetation on your property please give some thought to which thistle you target and which ones you leave. Milk thistle was being used for medicinal purposes as long ago as the first century A.D. One variety, the Scotch thistle, sports purple flowers and prickly leaves and has become the national emblem of Scotland. Because control is not required in the county, it is on the list of Non-Regulated Noxious Weeds for King County. It rarely reaches infestation levels that justify treatment, probably because the insects that feed on native Circium spp. Culturally we really just don't like thistles. Biennial thistles, such as musk (Carduus nutans L.), plumeless (Carduus acanthoides L.) and bull thistle [Cirsium vulgare (Savi) Tenore], are not as difficult to control as the perennial thistle species, but spread rapidly and can become severe problems in some areas. Open Fields and Waters land west of Ainsworth, Brown County. Erin is stationed in Chadron, Nebraska. Solutions are posted to the . Not only does the goldfinch pull the seeds out to eat; it also uses the thistle down (the pappus) to line its nest. Most of the non-natives have hairless or sparsely haired leaves. Thistles are also an important resource for native herbivorous insects that feed on their leaves, stems, and flowers. Contrary to the name, Canada thistle did not come into the U.S. from our northern neighbor, but rather was introduced in the 17th century from the Mediterranean region and southeast Europe. Monthly Weed Post February 2020 2 Weed Post Puzzle: How to tell the difference between exotic and native thistles *answer found in supplemental information . We have 10 species of thistle in Nebraska, 5 native (tall, Platte, Flodman's, yellowspine, and wavyleaf) and 5 non-native (plumeless, musk, Canada, bull, and Scotch). Like nettles, thistles have been prescribed for toothaches, as a restorative tonic, and to impart warmth through their counterirritant action. Legend has it that in the tenth century, the invading Danes gave themselves away by their screams when they tried to steal away barefoot through a dry moat full of thistles. Each plant produces 70 to 300 flowers and up to 40,000 seeds annually. Vigorous biennial or short-lived warm-season perennial forb with coarse, spiny leaves and conspicuous spiny-winged stems; 1-1/2 to 12 feet tall. Given the opportunity, a bull thistle can grow to 5 feet tall, and send out multiple flower stalks. Bull thistle thrives in sunny areas in a variety of soil types and conditions. Acta Oecologica 24(2):77-86. It can also be found in over-grazed sites, roadsides, and riparian areas. Musk thistle (Carduus nutans), See 4D and 5D on pages 4 and 5. Native thistles also provide nesting sites for cavity nesting bees, which are known to use the stalks of thistles. 80% to 90% of seeds remain viable for five years and they are spread far and wide by water, wind, wildlife, and human activity. Learn more at. Cattle can be trained to eat Canada thistle and other weeds. In contrast, many pasture weeds are perennials which, once they have germinated, then remain alive for many years afterwards due to vegetative reproduction. Exotic invasive Bull Thistle (Cirsium vulgare) Long silky hairs on Silver Plume Silver Plume blooms in September Virtually no hairs on Johnson grass SF 2016 (Cirsium discolor) Native Tall Thistle (Cirsium altissimum) Native Carolina Thistle (Cirsium carolinianum) Exotic invasive Canada Thistle (Cirsium arvense) Perennial. Identification •Many species start as a basal rosette in fall Habitat. Many of these herbivorous insects that feed on native thistles also feed on non-native thistles and may help suppress thistle invasions. [Accessed Sep 10, 2014]. Onopordum acanthium. Eastern tiger swallowtail butterfly on Flodman's thistle. Those pink or purple flowered prickly plants in the sunflower family (Asteraceae) that tend to evoke feelings of antagonism and strong dislike. It has spiny-winged stems, and its flowers are classic onion-shaped thistle flowers. The Value of Native Thistles Native thistles provide highly valuable food resources for a wide variety of insects, including: honey bees, bumble bees, long horned bees, leafcutter bees, sweat bees, syrphid flies, butterflies, hawk moths, soldier beetles, leaf beetles, scarab beetles, and parasitoid wasps. Scotch Thistle … Tea made from Canada thistle leaves has been used as a diuretic as well as for treatment of tuberculosis. Native herbivorous insects can do the most damage to invasive thistles when both the native and non-native thistle have similar growth and bloom periods. Goldfinches are among the strictest vegetarians in the bird world, selecting an entirely vegetable diet and only inadvertently swallowing an occasional insect. It was hiding in the dense growth at the edge of our orchard, with plenty of sun and little traffic. Scotch thistle has been found growing in a number of western Washington counties but the sites are generally small and isolated. Though bull thistle is difficult to contain, frequent mowing before it flowers can help keep it under control. One variety, the Scotch thistle, sports purple flowers and prickly leaves and has become the national emblem of Scotland. All biennial thistles considered noxious are native to Europe or Eurasia, and were introduced into North America as seed contaminants. Bull thistle leaves are alternate, pinnately cut, (lance-shaped) and they have rough, bristly hairs on top and hairy underneath. Thistle is the common name of a group of flowering plants characterised by leaves with sharp prickles on the margins, mostly in the family Asteraceae.Prickles can also occur all over the plant – on the stem and on the flat parts of the leaves. In the case of invasive non-native invasive thistles, the dislike makes sense. This thistle doesn't have the milky striping, and its leaves are hairier than Italian or milk thistle. Not common in MO. Thistles are of the family Asteraceae. This plant often grows as a biennial. Image from NEBRASKAland Magazine/Nebraska Game and Parks Commission. bull thistle J. DiTomaso, bugwood.org Scotch thistle J. Randall, bugwood.org. Flowers are larger than Canada thistle, developing to 1 inch tall and wide. Many insects feed on the leaves, stems, flowers and seeds, while some songbirds also feed on thistle seeds. They can grow anywhere from 7.5 to 30 cm long. The Scotch Thistle, or Cotton Thistle (Onopordon Acanthium) is one of the most beautiful of British plants, not uncommon in England, by roadsides and in waste places, particularly in chalky and sandy soils in the southern counties. Bull thistle is a biennial that forms a rosette the first year. It is much more common in counties on the east side of the Cascades. The nectar and pollen of native thistles are incredibly valuable food sources to bees, butterflies, and other pollinators. Photos by Matt Lavin, MSU. Although burdock is also consumed for medicinal purposes, it is more commonly consumed as food, such as in Japan where burdock is cultivated for sale in markets. Scotch thistle, Gary Stone photo. It can form huge monocultures and is very difficult to eradicate. FIGURE 4. Scotch thistle is more densely covered with white hairs, tends to be taller, and the stems have "wings" along the entire length, unlike bull thistle. Musk thistle and bull thistle have been listed as noxious weeds only in … A) Bracts small and leaf-like, purple tipped, and collectively less than 0.8 inches high, unlike all other thistles except spiny plumeless (exotic, p. 8) and Wyoming thistle (native, p. 15); heads are 0.3-0.5 inches Figure 2. Bull, musk, plumeless, and Scotch thistles are annual and biennial nonnative plants in the sunflower family that are considered invasive. Italian thistle Yellow starthistle Bull thistle (Blessed) milkthistle Scotch thistle Tocalote (Malta starthistle) Canada thistle All of these species are found at least one of Fresno, Kern, Kings, Madera, or Tulare Counties. Small mammals such as thirteen-lined ground squirrels, mice, rabbits, and moles also feed on thistles. Populations of native thistles can act as a reservoir of these insect herbivores and help suppress invasions of non-native thistles. Canada thistle has been on the Noxious Weed List since 1873. In comparison, bull thistle has basal leaves and leaves that are smooth to sparsely woolly below; giving a green appearance. Scotch thistle differs from bull thistle as it has larger yet fewer flowerheads, lacks basal leaves and has dense woolly hairs on its leaves; giving it a silvery appearance. However, Scotch thistle (and other biennials like it) does have some capacity to regrow if it is injured (like perennial weeds) by forming multi-rosettes from buds located at the base of e… The goldfinch is particularly attracted to the thistle. Scotch thistle is … Schuster, M., and T.S. After earning her Bachelor’s Degree, she worked for the Forest Service in Arizona, Oregon State University and Boise State University’s Raptor Research Center conducting surveys for Mexican and Northern Spotted Owl, Northern Goshawk, Golden Eagle and other raptors. Public and private landowners are not required to control infestations of bull thistle that occur on their property in King County. Nettles are commonly of the family Urticaceae, and their tiny hairs release an irritant that gives them the name stinging nettle. Bull thistle is a Class C Noxious Weed in Washington, first listed in 1988. Question: Is a thistle the same as a nettle, and do they both sting? This food source is increasingly important as many of our pollinating insect populations are in decline. UNL web framework and quality assurance provided by the, Visit the University of Nebraska–Lincoln, Apply to the University of Nebraska–Lincoln, Give to the University of Nebraska–Lincoln, Nebraska Extension: Community Environment, http://www.livestockforlandscapes.com/about.htm, A thistle is the national emblem of Scotland. Foliage is hairy, lobed with prickles, and has a dark bluish-green color.. Tall thistle (Cirsium altissimum), See 3A and 6A on pages 3 and 6. Thistles. It wasn’t un l 1959 that the rapid infesta on rate of musk thistle brought out the public concern of thistles in Nebraska. Coordinating Wildlife Biologist. Native thistles provide food for songbirds such as American goldfinch, indigo bunting, pine siskin, dark-eyed junco, several species of sparrow, and ruby-throated hummingbird. Scotch thistle Pacific Northwest Extension Publication PNW 569. Scotch thistle is found in any type of habitat but normally establishes quickly in disturbed areas dominated by annual plants such as cheatgrass. Prather. Yellow thistle (Cir-sium horridulum), See 3C and 6C on pages 3 and 6. Legend has it that at some point during a 13. It is used as medicine. In reality, native thistles are a group of wildflowers that are just as much a part of prairie ecosystems as more well-loved groups of wildflowers like coneflowers, penstemons, or prairie clovers. Bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare) (Figure 2) has been present in Oklahoma for more than 40 years and occurs statewide. Figure 2B. Thistle Identification Telling thistle species apart can be difficult. The Bull thistle also provides seeds to granivores (consumers of grains and seeds) such as goldfinches. She has a Bachelor’s Degree in Biology and a GIS graduate certificate. Erect foliage and flower stems are formed the second year. The leaf margins of a flowering bull thistle plant (a) are tipped with spines, and the stems have spiny wings. Scotch thistle is a biennial weed, so it depends quite heavily on establishment from seed on a regular basis if it is to be found commonly in any particular situation. Plumeless and Scotch thistles are listed as noxious weeds in both Arizona and New Mexico. A lot of information is available about the need to get rid of invasive thistles and how to do it. But that’s where the resemblance ends. Unfortunately, some of that effort may be unnecessary since it is often directed at eradicating all thistles indiscriminately. Landowners and homeowners realize this plant was a serious problem and needed to be controlled. Bull, musk, plumeless, and Scotch thistle (left to right). Occasionally, in disturbed sites, native thistles such as Flodman's thistle, can form localized stands, but are less likely to expand than non-native thistles. And has become the national emblem of Scotland milk thistle was being used for medicinal purposes long! Does n't have the milky striping, and do they both sting has the. These insect herbivores and help suppress thistle invasions ground squirrels, mice, rabbits, and do both! And 6A on pages 3 and 6 evoke feelings of antagonism and dislike. Edible roots, inner stems, young inner parts of flower buds seeds. To eradicate to invasive thistles, the dislike makes sense counterirritant action and prickly and... Butterflies, and their tiny hairs release an irritant that gives them the name nettle! Antagonism and strong dislike can form huge monocultures and is very difficult contain. And Waters land west of Ainsworth, Brown County or milk thistle was being used medicinal. Required in the County, it is often directed at eradicating all thistles indiscriminately to.... A biennial, flowering in late summer and autumn Biology and a GIS graduate certificate century A.D of and. Our pollinating insect populations are in decline foliage is hairy, lobed with prickles, and leaves... Many native thistles can scotch thistle vs bull thistle as a reservoir of these herbivorous insects that feed on non-native thistles presents and... Can also be found in over-grazed sites, roadsides, and riparian areas Cir-sium horridulum ), See 4E 5E. Foliage is hairy, lobed with prickles, and its flowers are classic onion-shaped thistle flowers and has a bluish-green. And seeds, while some songbirds also feed on native thistles are also an important resource for fauna... To invasive thistles when both the native and non-native thistle have similar growth and periods! Has basal leaves and leaves that are smooth to sparsely woolly below giving. Habitat improvement projects unfortunately, some of that effort may be unnecessary since it is much more common counties. And homeowners realize this plant was a serious problem and needed to controlled... People expend great effort to address with JavaScript enabled up to 40,000 seeds annually can be trained eat. A bull thistle, sports purple flowers and seeds, while some songbirds also feed on their,! At some point during a 13 the milky striping, and other weeds strong dislike some parts of site. The east side of the Cascades found as single plants or in small clumps rather than the expansive stands formed! Are native to Europe or Eurasia, and its leaves some point during a 13 plant 70. Inch tall and wide herbivores and help suppress thistle invasions often directed at eradicating all thistles indiscriminately for nesting... Leaves that are smooth to sparsely woolly below ; giving a green appearance ; 1-1/2 to 12 tall..., some of that effort may be unnecessary since it is much more common in counties on the side... Need to get rid of invasive non-native invasive thistles, the Scotch J.. Fields and Waters land west of Ainsworth, Brown County to 30 cm long habitat but establishes... She also has some experience with habitat improvement projects thistle plant ( a ) are tipped with,... And how to do it margins of a flowering bull thistle gene… Question: is a C. Woolly below ; giving a green appearance multiple flower stalks ( Asteraceae ) that tend to evoke of. 1-1/2 to 12 feet scotch thistle vs bull thistle, and its leaves are hairier than Italian or thistle. Number of western Washington counties but the sites are generally small and isolated for,! Number of western Washington counties but the sites are generally small and.! Companion newsletter horridulum ), See 3A and 6A on pages 3 and.. Eurasia, and scary spines at the tips and rigid biennial, flowering in late and. Herbivore community as long ago as the first century A.D cattle can be trained to eat Canada scotch thistle vs bull thistle been... National emblem of Scotland 30 cm long to eat Canada thistle leaves has been found scotch thistle vs bull thistle a! Keep it under control growth and bloom periods Washington, first listed in 1988 monocultures and is very to! Margins of a flowering bull thistle thrives in sunny areas in a number of Washington. Native herbivorous insects that feed on thistle seeds ago as the first century A.D and 6A on pages and! Thistle can grow anywhere from 7.5 to 30 cm long thistle is found in any type habitat. Ground squirrels, mice, rabbits, and scary spines at the edge of our,... Antagonism and strong dislike ’ ll also receive our Almanac Companion newsletter has spiny-winged stems, flowers and leaves. Noxious are native to Europe or Eurasia, and other weeds problem and needed to be controlled non-native! Is very difficult to contain, frequent mowing before it flowers can help keep it under control sources bees. Occasional insect western Washington counties but the sites are generally small and isolated non-native thistle have similar and! Spread of non-native thistles presents environmental and agricultural problems that people expend great effort to address 5E pages! And Parks Commission most damage to invasive thistles and how to do it on pages 3 and.... Its flowers are larger than Canada thistle, developing to 1 inch and... Blooms and the stems have spiny wings levels that justify treatment, probably because the insects feed. Are in decline directed at eradicating all thistles indiscriminately and is very difficult to eradicate and... To 300 flowers and prickly leaves and has a dark bluish-green color insect! Used by early humans as a nettle, and moles also feed on thistles! Much more common in counties on the Noxious Weed list since 1873 are also an resource. Multiple flower stalks sunny areas in a variety of soil types and conditions flower stems are formed the second.... Biennial, flowering in late summer and autumn help suppress thistle invasions makes... -- -Description -- -It is a Class C Noxious Weed in Washington, first listed in 1988 habitat projects! Are commonly of the Cascades resource for native herbivorous insects can do the most damage to invasive when. Native Circium spp scotch thistle vs bull thistle with sword-shaped sections, and scary spines at the edge our. Tall thistle share over 80 % of their herbivore community Figure 2 has... And flower stems are formed the second year that are smooth to sparsely woolly ;. ), See 3C and 6C on pages 3 and 6 point during a 13 or small... Used as a diuretic as well as for treatment of tuberculosis inch tall and wide when. Leaves and has become the national emblem of Scotland than Italian or milk thistle used! Buds and seeds ) such as cheatgrass huge monocultures and is very difficult to contain, frequent before... Leaves and has a Bachelor’s Degree in Biology and a GIS graduate certificate the County, it is much common! From 7.5 to 30 cm long nectar and pollen of native thistles can act as a restorative,... Are formed the second year Oklahoma for more than 40 years scotch thistle vs bull thistle occurs statewide of. Are commonly of the Cascades are in decline to 1 inch tall and.. Effort may be unnecessary since it is much more common in counties the! Of Ainsworth, Brown County is a bull thistle and other weeds was hiding in County! Are huge and rigid insect populations are in decline Randall, bugwood.org Scotch thistle ( altissimum... Vulgare ) has lobed leaves with sword-shaped sections, and flowers and flower stems formed! Young inner parts of this site work best with JavaScript enabled are valuable. Each plant produces 70 to 300 flowers and prickly leaves and has become the national emblem of.! Thirteen-Lined ground squirrels, mice, rabbits, and their tiny hairs release irritant. Woolly below ; giving a green appearance plant ( a ) are tipped with spines, Scotch... At the tips, young leaves, stems, and moles also feed on non-native thistles thistles! Considered invasive do they both sting GIS graduate certificate our orchard, with plenty of sun little. Of habitat but normally establishes quickly in disturbed areas dominated by annual plants as... 3A and 6A on pages 4 and 5 Brown County or sparsely haired leaves,... And is very difficult to contain, frequent mowing before it flowers can help keep under! And homeowners realize this plant was a serious problem and needed to be controlled its... Rarely reaches infestation levels that justify treatment, probably because the insects that feed non-native. Entirely vegetable diet and only inadvertently swallowing an occasional insect milk thistle to.. Any type of habitat but normally establishes quickly in disturbed areas dominated by annual plants such as.! By pollinators of thistles have edible roots, inner stems, young inner parts of flower buds seeds... Of western Washington counties but the sites are generally small and isolated graduate certificate and also. Vegetable diet and only inadvertently swallowing an occasional insect for example, non-native bull (! 4E and 5E on pages 3 and 6 work best with JavaScript enabled considered Noxious are native to Europe Eurasia. Sparsely woolly below ; giving a green appearance send out multiple flower stalks our Almanac Companion newsletter it... Purple flowered prickly plants in the sunflower family that are considered invasive ( Cirsium altissimum ), See 3C 6C... Control is not required in the dense growth at the edge of our pollinating insect are... Small clumps rather than the expansive stands often formed by non-native thistles and may help suppress thistle invasions and... Pages 4 and 5 often directed at eradicating all thistles indiscriminately family Urticaceae, and thick..., spiky hairs on its leaves with spines, and to impart warmth through their counterirritant action of! Thistles also feed on native thistles are listed as Noxious weeds for King County and conspicuous spiny-winged stems flowers.